NGC 2168 vs NGC 2632

Two open clusters of the northern winter and spring, differing mainly in scale. NGC 2632, the Beehive, reaches magnitude 3.10 across 108.60 arcminutes — nearly two degrees, or four times the width of the full Moon. NGC 2168 is fainter at 5.10 and more compact at 24.00 arcminutes. The Beehive's greater total light does not translate into a denser image: its surface brightness near 13.0 magnitudes per square arcminute falls behind the 11.7 of NGC 2168. Both resolve into individual stars in modest instruments, which makes surface brightness less decisive here than it is for nebulae, and the practical distinction is one of field of view.

Property comparison

Property NGC 2168 NGC 2632
Object type Star Cluster Star Cluster
Catalogue designation NGC 2168 NGC 2632
Integrated magnitude 5.10 3.10
Apparent size 24′ (24′) 1.8° (108.6′)
Mean surface brightness 11.7 mag/arcmin² 13.0 mag/arcmin²
Position (J2000) RA 6h, Dec +24° RA 8h, Dec +19°
Sky region Northern sky Northern sky

Mean surface brightness is derived from the integrated magnitude and the apparent diameter; higher values mean a fainter, more diffuse surface.

Full data for each object: NGC 2168 · NGC 2632

Key differences

Key Differences

  • NGC 2632 is brighter at magnitude 3.10 against 5.10 for NGC 2168.
  • NGC 2632 spans 108.60 arcminutes; NGC 2168 covers 24.00, roughly a quarter as wide.
  • NGC 2168 has the higher surface brightness, near 11.7 magnitudes per square arcminute against 13.0.
  • NGC 2632 is a naked-eye patch from a dark site; NGC 2168 generally requires binoculars.
  • Declinations of +19° and +24° place both high in the northern sky within weeks of each other.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Which cluster is visible without optical aid?
NGC 2632, the Beehive, at magnitude 3.10. It appears as a hazy patch to the unaided eye from a dark site. NGC 2168 at magnitude 5.10 sits close to the naked-eye limit and is normally a binocular object.
Which shows better in binoculars?
NGC 2632, whose 108.60-arcminute extent matches a typical binocular field. NGC 2168 at 24.00 arcminutes is better suited to a small telescope at low power, where its higher surface brightness resolves more stars per field.
When are they best observed?
Both culminate in the northern winter and early spring, at declinations +24° and +19°, and pass high overhead for mid-northern observers.
← All deep sky comparisons